Introduction
In cases involving
severe allegations—such as physical assault, stalking, or sexual
coercion—complaints are frequently registered simultaneously under the POSH Act before the Internal Committee (IC)
and under criminal law, such as the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), through a
Police First Information Report (FIR). This dual track creates operational
confusion for employers, with respondents often arguing that the IC inquiry
should be stayed or paused until the police investigation or criminal trial
concludes.
1. Independence of IC
Inquiries and Criminal Proceedings
Indian courts have
repeatedly clarified that an IC inquiry and criminal proceedings operate in
entirely independent legal domains. A criminal trial evaluates offences against
the State under the higher evidentiary threshold of "beyond a reasonable
doubt," whereas a POSH inquiry evaluates workplace misconduct under
service rules using the civil standard of "preponderance of
probability."
Because the objectives,
forums, and standards of proof are distinct, the pendency of a police
investigation or criminal trial does not automatically stay an IC proceeding.
2. Statutory Timelines
Under Section 11
For the IC, conducting a
parallel inquiry requires strict adherence to its statutory timelines under
Section 11, regardless of police involvement.
Pausing an internal
inquiry while waiting for law enforcement or criminal courts—which often take
years—defeats the statutory mandate of completing POSH inquiries within 90 days.
The IC must proceed independently,
relying on the evidence, witness statements, and documents presented directly
before it during the domestic inquiry.
3. Evidence Sharing and
Independent Statement Recording
Parallel proceedings
demand heightened procedural caution regarding statement recording and evidence
sharing.
Statements recorded by
the police or court pleadings are not automatically imported into the IC
record. The IC must independently record witness testimonies during its own
proceedings.
Simultaneously, the IC
must maintain strict confidentiality under Section 16, ensuring that internal
inquiry records are not leaked to external media, though statutory authorities
like investigating officers or courts may subpoena records through due process
of law.
4. Maintaining Confidentiality During Parallel
Proceedings
Confidentiality remains
a critical responsibility of the Internal Committee when criminal proceedings
are taking place simultaneously.
The IC must protect
inquiry records, witness statements, and sensitive information in accordance
with Section 16 of the POSH Act. Any sharing of records with external
authorities must follow the applicable legal process.
Conclusion
Understanding the legal
independence of parallel proceedings ensures that the IC fulfills its statutory
duty without administrative hesitation.
By maintaining a firm
boundary between internal workplace discipline and external criminal law, the
committee protects the complainant's right to a speedy workplace inquiry while
respecting the broader framework of criminal justice.

No comments:
Post a Comment